|
Post by Outlast on Feb 23, 2014 2:12:45 GMT -5
With Brooke's comment I realized we don't have this thread, so:
The Amazing 1. Heroes vs Villains 2. Philippines 3. Micronesia 4. Pearl Islands 5. China
The Great 6. Gabon 7. Amazon 8. Australian Outback 9. Exile Island 10. Blood vs Water
The OK 11. Tocantins 12. Nicaragua 13. Caramoan 14. Borneo 15. Vanuatu 16 Marquesas
The "Meh" 17. Guatemala 18. Palau 19. All-Stars
The "Bleh" 20. Samoa 21. Thailand 22. Africa 23. Cook Islands 24. Fiji
The Down Right Ugly 25. One World 26. South Pacific 27. Redemption Island
I feel like the only one I really have to explain is Caramoan at 13. I know that most feel this is the worst season of all time, and I can't say I can really justify my liking for it, but I think it's because I started watching during Samoa. I guess that makes me used to edit-whoring, OTT characters, and strategizing 24/7. I haven't re-watched since it aired, but looking back and remembering some stuff, especially the pre-merge, it would probably drop below Guatemala.
|
|
|
Post by Nate on Feb 23, 2014 2:36:40 GMT -5
I'll rank mine tomorrow. I still haven't seen Marquesas, Fiji or Africa though.
|
|
eaoltis
Rookie
Extraordinarily brilliant!
Posts: 231
Hometown: Santa Barbara, CA
Favorite Reality Show: Survivor
|
Post by eaoltis on Feb 23, 2014 14:58:37 GMT -5
Top 10 Supremacy Phillippines- Fall 2012, good times. Cagayan- 👑👑 Tony! Vanuatu- Best underdog story. Gabon- Made no sense, I love it! DvsG- My favorite cast. Cambodia- The hype for this season, was unreal. KR- Modern season, no advantages played, awesome. Nicaragua- Yes!!! HvsV- An elite group of players. MvsGenX- The winner was a surprise. Fantastic Seasons Guatemala Australia EI Amazon Samoa HHH Africa Marquesas Great Seasons WaW BvsW SJDS Fiji Thailand Good Seasons SP CI China PI Palau Tocantins 41 a** Micronesia OW Borneo Not a Fan WA- Coronation edit. Caramoan- What fans? What favorites? GI- Boring IoI- Finale episode was nice, though. Bottom 3 GC- Why? RI- Jeff's dream season, ewww! EoE- Not cannon.
Can, I reiterate how bad EoE is? Its everything wrong with modern day Survivor. I loathe it.
|
|
|
Post by Nate on Feb 23, 2014 16:45:44 GMT -5
01. Gabon 02. Micronesia 03. Vanuatu 04. Philippines 05. Heroes vs. Villains 06. Pearl Islands 07. Exile Island 08. Tocantins 09. Guatemala 10. Blood vs. Water 11. China 12. All-Stars 13. Cook Islands 14. Palau 15. Amazon 16. Australian Outback 17. Nicaragua 18. Borneo 19. Caramoan 20. One World 21. Samoa 22. South Pacific 23. Redemption Island 24. Thailand
Gabon is my number one because it is perfect in every way except Sugar not trying hard enough to win at the end and the jury failing to realize she owned them. Vanuatu is special to me because it's the first one I watched when I started watching older seasons and Chris is a boss. I have Guatemala ranked pretty high which I actually didn't expect myself to do, but that season is very underrated in my opinion and I have no idea why Rafe, Judd, Jamie, Gary, or hell even Cindy, Danni or Brian haven't been asked back. They were all fun to watch. Palau actually was not a good season but I ranked it in the middle because the challenges were the best they've ever been and Stephanie made a good amount of the season fun to watch.
|
|
|
Post by Brooke on Feb 23, 2014 17:39:38 GMT -5
eaoltis: I really enjoyed Samoa. It's in my top 10.
|
|
eaoltis
Rookie
Extraordinarily brilliant!
Posts: 231
Hometown: Santa Barbara, CA
Favorite Reality Show: Survivor
|
Post by eaoltis on Feb 23, 2014 20:21:03 GMT -5
Yay! I knew I wasn't the only one.
|
|
|
Post by Darebear55 on Feb 24, 2014 12:39:03 GMT -5
I can't rank the seasons because I've only seen majority of them once but Samoa is definitely one that sticks out. Even though it had Russell who I could not stand, it was really amazing to see how a tribe that had a huge advantage going into a merge, just get destroyed. Based on the strategy, it was a great season.
|
|
|
Post by Brooke on Feb 24, 2014 16:24:03 GMT -5
1. Micronesia 2. Blood vs Water 3. Heroes vs Villains 4. Australian Outback 5. Borneo 6. All-Stars 7. Amazon 8. Samoa 9. China 10. Africa 11. Tocantins 12. Exile Island 13. Vanuatu 14 Marquesas 15. Redemption Island 16. Palau 17. Guatemala 18. Cook Islands 19. Pearl Islands 20. Gabon 21. Caramoan 22. One World 23. South Pacific 24. Nicaragua 25. Philippines 26. Fiji 27. Thailand This is my rough draft of this. I want to go more in depth, but this is off first impressions (some I haven't seen in a while or only have seen once), but I'm definitely going to go back and refurbish my list and give reasons later on.
|
|
|
Post by Jhonmarco on Feb 24, 2014 16:30:38 GMT -5
Whoa didn't expect BVW to make top 2.
I've only seen like 6 seasons, so I'll wait until I at least see 4 more to make my ranking.
|
|
|
Post by Brooke on Feb 24, 2014 16:50:32 GMT -5
Whoa didn't expect BVW to make top 2. I've only seen like 6 seasons, so I'll wait until I at least see 4 more to make my ranking. BvW is super fresh in my mind. I'm also a HUGE Tyson fan and this was the first season I watched marathon style (not live). So it's up there for now. When I go more in depth, we'll see how I feel still. I love any and all ties in this game. Means that it's great. When they went to rocks. WOW. Ever since Season 4, I always wanted someone to have the balls to keep it tied up to go to rocks. The more drama the merrier as well, another reason I love Samoa so much. A tribe of underdogs overtaking a tribe that was so dominate. Same with All-Stars. To see Rob convince someone on another tribe to keep Amber....there are just moments that make Survivor top notch.
|
|
|
Post by Jhonmarco on Feb 24, 2014 16:57:39 GMT -5
Whoa didn't expect BVW to make top 2. I've only seen like 6 seasons, so I'll wait until I at least see 4 more to make my ranking. BvW is super fresh in my mind. I'm also a HUGE Tyson fan and this was the first season I watched marathon style (not live). So it's up there for now. When I go more in depth, we'll see how I feel still. I love any and all ties in this game. Means that it's great. When they went to rocks. WOW. Ever since Season 4, I always wanted someone to have the balls to keep it tied up to go to rocks. The more drama the merrier as well, another reason I love Samoa so much. A tribe of underdogs overtaking a tribe that was so dominate. Same with All-Stars. To see Rob convince someone on another tribe to keep Amber....there are just moments that make Survivor top notch. I did enjoy it as well. I just wish they would have gotten rid of RI, post-merge. It's always confused why they'd let one person reenter the game when they've missed out on a sh*tload of TCs and they could end up potentially winning. Tyson was also a fun villain to root against. Brad's downfall was nice to see and I definitely wanna see Vytas/Hayden/Cierra again.
|
|
|
Post by Brooke on Feb 24, 2014 17:02:10 GMT -5
BvW is super fresh in my mind. I'm also a HUGE Tyson fan and this was the first season I watched marathon style (not live). So it's up there for now. When I go more in depth, we'll see how I feel still. I love any and all ties in this game. Means that it's great. When they went to rocks. WOW. Ever since Season 4, I always wanted someone to have the balls to keep it tied up to go to rocks. The more drama the merrier as well, another reason I love Samoa so much. A tribe of underdogs overtaking a tribe that was so dominate. Same with All-Stars. To see Rob convince someone on another tribe to keep Amber....there are just moments that make Survivor top notch. I did enjoy it as well. I just wish they would have gotten rid of RI, post-merge. It's always confused why they'd let one person reenter the game when they've missed out on a sh*tload of TCs and they could end up potentially winning. Tyson was also a fun villain to root against. Brad's downfall was nice to see and I definitely wanna see Vytas/Hayden/Cierra again.YES! I absolutely couldn't stand Hayden on Big Brother (other than he was a hot body to stare at), but on Survivor he was absolutely the person to root for. Cierra was also someone I didn't expect to like, but loved. I'd also love to see Katie again, just because she was rocked out.
|
|
|
Post by Jhonmarco on Apr 20, 2014 22:18:15 GMT -5
So far how does Cagayan rank? I'm hearing people giving it top 3 status on other forums.
|
|
|
Post by Nate on Apr 20, 2014 22:21:20 GMT -5
So far how does Cagayan rank? I'm hearing people giving it top 3 status on other forums. So far....although the seasons always have to sink in before a real ranking because it's always awesome while it's happening 01. Gabon 02. Micronesia 03. Vanuatu 04. Philippines 05. Heroes vs. Villains 06. Cagayan07. Pearl Islands 08. Exile Island 09. Tocantins 10. Guatemala 11. Blood vs. Water 12. China 13. All-Stars 14. Cook Islands 15. Palau 16. Amazon 17. Australian Outback 18. Nicaragua 19. Borneo 20. Caramoan 21. One World 22. Samoa 23. South Pacific 24. Redemption Island 25. Thailand If the game keeps going how it's gone, it might go up past Philippines and possibly Vanuatu.
|
|
|
Post by Jhonmarco on Apr 20, 2014 22:26:48 GMT -5
So far how does Cagayan rank? I'm hearing people giving it top 3 status on other forums. So far....although the seasons always have to sink in before a real ranking because it's always awesome while it's happening 01. Gabon 02. Micronesia 03. Vanuatu 04. Philippines 05. Heroes vs. Villains 06. Cagayan07. Pearl Islands 08. Exile Island 09. Tocantins 10. Guatemala 11. Blood vs. Water 12. China 13. All-Stars 14. Cook Islands 15. Palau 16. Amazon 17. Australian Outback 18. Nicaragua 19. Borneo 20. Caramoan 21. One World 22. Samoa 23. South Pacific 24. Redemption Island 25. Thailand If the game keeps going how it's gone, it might go up past Philippines and possibly Vanuatu. Maybe I need to rewatch Philippines again, because I remember Philippines having a slow start somewhat, still having a good cast tho. While Cagayan has had blindsides after blindsides, I think it's pretty insane how open the game is at F8 still, but let's see.
|
|
|
Post by Nate on Apr 20, 2014 22:30:50 GMT -5
So far....although the seasons always have to sink in before a real ranking because it's always awesome while it's happening 01. Gabon 02. Micronesia 03. Vanuatu 04. Philippines 05. Heroes vs. Villains 06. Cagayan07. Pearl Islands 08. Exile Island 09. Tocantins 10. Guatemala 11. Blood vs. Water 12. China 13. All-Stars 14. Cook Islands 15. Palau 16. Amazon 17. Australian Outback 18. Nicaragua 19. Borneo 20. Caramoan 21. One World 22. Samoa 23. South Pacific 24. Redemption Island 25. Thailand If the game keeps going how it's gone, it might go up past Philippines and possibly Vanuatu. Maybe I need to rewatch Philippines again, because I remember Philippines having a slow start somewhat, still having a good cast tho. While Cagayan has had blindsides after blindsides, I think it's pretty insane how open the game is at F8 still, but let's see. Well for me, I'm also taking into account the cast. Philippines literally had the best newbie cast I have ever seen in any season in my opinion, while Cagayan also has an above average cast because everyone has contributed something so far except for Jefra but not as good as Philippines. The Cagayan people are less likeable overall. If this season stays how it's been, it will probably go right under Gabon actually.
|
|
|
Post by Brooke on Apr 20, 2014 22:34:15 GMT -5
Philippines was awful...
|
|
|
Post by Nate on Apr 20, 2014 22:34:57 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by Jhonmarco on Apr 20, 2014 22:35:33 GMT -5
Maybe I need to rewatch Philippines again, because I remember Philippines having a slow start somewhat, still having a good cast tho. While Cagayan has had blindsides after blindsides, I think it's pretty insane how open the game is at F8 still, but let's see. Well for me, I'm also taking into account the cast. Philippines literally had the best newbie cast I have ever seen in any season in my opinion, while Cagayan also has an above average cast because everyone has contributed something so far except for Jefra but not as good as Philippines. The Cagayan people are less likeable overall. If this season stays how it's been, it will probably go right under Gabon actually. Not when Abi Maria was on that cast....haha, but yeah I get what you're saying.
|
|
|
Post by Brooke on Apr 20, 2014 22:36:25 GMT -5
No... Really the only good people were Malcolm and Skupin.
|
|