|
Post by Joey on Mar 4, 2016 18:17:24 GMT -5
What if Melissa McNulty didn't quit in Fiji and they divided the tribes by race again?
|
|
|
Post by Helen of Troy on Mar 8, 2016 15:43:30 GMT -5
What if rudy never took his hand off immunity idol? I don't just mean what are the implications for Borneo but what does that mean for survivor as a whole if Rudy Boesch is the first winner of Survivor.
|
|
|
Post by Jhonmarco on Mar 8, 2016 15:49:31 GMT -5
What if rudy never took his hand off immunity idol? I don't just mean what are the implications for Borneo but what does that mean for survivor as a whole if Rudy Boesch is the first winner of Survivor. I feel like in general Richard winning changed the game and made it into what it is today.
|
|
|
Post by Helen of Troy on Mar 8, 2016 16:15:08 GMT -5
What if rudy never took his hand off immunity idol? I don't just mean what are the implications for Borneo but what does that mean for survivor as a whole if Rudy Boesch is the first winner of Survivor. I feel like in general Richard winning changed the game and made it into what it is today. Does survivor exsist 32 seasons later if Rudy wins Borneo?
|
|
|
Post by Donald on Mar 8, 2016 16:16:31 GMT -5
What if Amanda didnt let Danielle keep the hidden immunity clue?
|
|
|
Post by briqsquad on Mar 8, 2016 18:34:13 GMT -5
What if rudy never took his hand off immunity idol? I don't just mean what are the implications for Borneo but what does that mean for survivor as a whole if Rudy Boesch is the first winner of Survivor. I feel like in general Richard winning changed the game and made it into what it is today. What is the reason for this? I really don't understand this statement
|
|
|
Post by Jhonmarco on Mar 8, 2016 18:50:59 GMT -5
I feel like in general Richard winning changed the game and made it into what it is today. What is the reason for this? I really don't understand this statement It allowed for more of a precedent for alliances when the show was originally meant for someone with great survival skills and a lot more likable to win. The next season you saw people trying to act as nice as they could since morality and the show was still a huge deal, but secretly playing like Hatch was. If Kelly or Rudy win, it sets the show off to an entirely new pace. Things like flipping on alliances didn't become a thing until season 4, but Richard changed what the show was supposed to be.
|
|
|
Post by Helen of Troy on Mar 8, 2016 19:44:49 GMT -5
What is the reason for this? I really don't understand this statement It allowed for more of a precedent for alliances when the show was originally meant for someone with great survival skills and a lot more likable to win. The next season you saw people trying to act as nice as they could since morality and the show was still a huge deal, but secretly playing like Hatch was. If Kelly or Rudy win, it sets the show off to an entirely new pace. Things like flipping on alliances didn't become a thing until season 4, but Richard changed what the show was supposed to be. Or we can look at a more direct path. If richard doesn't win, he doesn't go out as soon as he did in allstars, so the Mogo Mogo tribe doesn't suck as much, boston rob doesn't make FTC lex probably does. Boston Rob not making FTC means no Boston Rob on HvV, which means no Rob vs Russell which means no RI. Because Rudy let go RI happened, c'mon Rudy you done f*cked up.
|
|
|
Post by Jhonmarco on Mar 8, 2016 19:47:02 GMT -5
It allowed for more of a precedent for alliances when the show was originally meant for someone with great survival skills and a lot more likable to win. The next season you saw people trying to act as nice as they could since morality and the show was still a huge deal, but secretly playing like Hatch was. If Kelly or Rudy win, it sets the show off to an entirely new pace. Things like flipping on alliances didn't become a thing until season 4, but Richard changed what the show was supposed to be. Or we can look at a more direct path. If richard doesn't win, he doesn't go out as soon as he did in allstars, so the Mogo Mogo tribe doesn't suck as much, boston rob doesn't make FTC lex probably does. Boston Rob not making FTC means no Boston Rob on HvV, which means no Rob vs Russell which means no RI. Because Rudy let go RI happened, c'mon Rudy you done f*cked up. I love how you casually threw in Lex probably makes ftc lmao
|
|
|
Post by Helen of Troy on Mar 8, 2016 19:56:46 GMT -5
Or we can look at a more direct path. If richard doesn't win, he doesn't go out as soon as he did in allstars, so the Mogo Mogo tribe doesn't suck as much, boston rob doesn't make FTC lex probably does. Boston Rob not making FTC means no Boston Rob on HvV, which means no Rob vs Russell which means no RI. Because Rudy let go RI happened, c'mon Rudy you done f*cked up. I love how you casually threw in Lex probably makes ftc lmao Love lex, but in all seriousness I see the Boran 3 as the F3 again and the Survivor equivalent of Chilltown and looked at forever as the GOAT alliance. I just feel like if Lex was more comfortable then Ethan makes the merge and they meet up with big tom and and the f7 is probably split Lex Tom Ethan Kathy vs Rich/ Shi Ann vs Jerri. Bottom 3 get pagonged Kathy gets 4th and Boran does what they always should have done.
|
|
|
Post by briqsquad on Mar 8, 2016 19:57:02 GMT -5
What is the reason for this? I really don't understand this statement It allowed for more of a precedent for alliances when the show was originally meant for someone with great survival skills and a lot more likable to win. The next season you saw people trying to act as nice as they could since morality and the show was still a huge deal, but secretly playing like Hatch was. If Kelly or Rudy win, it sets the show off to an entirely new pace. Things like flipping on alliances didn't become a thing until season 4, but Richard changed what the show was supposed to be. do you think he changed it completely or that it was going to be inevitable to change but on a different season? I feel like the show was inevitable to go down this path eventually.
|
|
|
Post by Jhonmarco on Mar 8, 2016 20:02:36 GMT -5
It allowed for more of a precedent for alliances when the show was originally meant for someone with great survival skills and a lot more likable to win. The next season you saw people trying to act as nice as they could since morality and the show was still a huge deal, but secretly playing like Hatch was. If Kelly or Rudy win, it sets the show off to an entirely new pace. Things like flipping on alliances didn't become a thing until season 4, but Richard changed what the show was supposed to be. do you think he changed it completely or that it was going to be inevitable to change but on a different season? I feel like the show was inevitable to go down this path eventually. I think he had some influence and do think it's possible game changes anyway due to certain players, but I think it could have taken a lot longer and it could have affected how much people still wanted to watch if it was just about survival skills
|
|
|
Post by Jhonmarco on Mar 8, 2016 20:04:16 GMT -5
I love how you casually threw in Lex probably makes ftc lmao Love lex, but in all seriousness I see the Boran 3 as the F3 again and the Survivor equivalent of Chilltown and looked at forever as the GOAT alliance. I just feel like if Lex was more comfortable then Ethan makes the merge and they meet up with big tom and and the f7 is probably split Lex Tom Ethan Kathy vs Rich/ Shi Ann vs Jerri. Bottom 3 get pagonged Kathy gets 4th and Boran does what they always should have done. I wasn't disagreeing lol just noting. It'd probably help Lex's reputation over the years too, instead of everyone remembering him for his super bitter jury speech and negative run on all stars.
|
|
|
Post by Helen of Troy on Mar 8, 2016 20:16:25 GMT -5
Love lex, but in all seriousness I see the Boran 3 as the F3 again and the Survivor equivalent of Chilltown and looked at forever as the GOAT alliance. I just feel like if Lex was more comfortable then Ethan makes the merge and they meet up with big tom and and the f7 is probably split Lex Tom Ethan Kathy vs Rich/ Shi Ann vs Jerri. Bottom 3 get pagonged Kathy gets 4th and Boran does what they always should have done. I wasn't disagreeing lol just noting. It'd probably help Lex's reputation over the years too, instead of everyone remembering him for his super bitter jury speech and negative run on all stars. Id also like to add in this situation Im not sure who wins. I would expect a Lex vs Ethan FTC and I dont know if Ethan having won before outweighs the fact he is definitely more likable than Lex. But lex could also take big tom even tho I think Big tom beats them both which would be crazy to live in a world where the man who gave a speech about a hyenas a**hole later wins survivor.
|
|
|
Post by briqsquad on Mar 8, 2016 21:07:25 GMT -5
do you think he changed it completely or that it was going to be inevitable to change but on a different season? I feel like the show was inevitable to go down this path eventually. I think he had some influence and do think it's possible game changes anyway due to certain players, but I think it could have taken a lot longer and it could have affected how much people still wanted to watch if it was just about survival skills Ok I can see that. Maybe Brian Heidik would've been the face of Survivor in the early days. His personal life would've the Kim and kanye back then tbh
|
|
|
Post by Nate on Jun 26, 2016 10:46:06 GMT -5
What if Jeff didn't injure his foot in Palau?
They probably would have won the third immunity challenge and who knows what could have happened after that.
|
|